What a monthly ranking report should actually tell you
Many agencies send a PDF of charts nobody reads. A useful report answers four questions in plain words. Here they are, with the numbers from a real site.
If you pay someone to look after your site, you probably receive a report. Often it is a PDF with a dozen charts, a line that goes up and a sentence saying things are going well. You open it, you do not know what to look at and you close it. That report is not for you. It is for the agency, to show that it did something.
A report worth reading answers four questions a business owner actually has. It does so in words first and in numbers second. Every number can be checked in the tool it came from. Below are the four questions, what to look for in each and how it looks on a real site: the private clinic from our case study, three months after launch.
Question 1: did more people see us for searches that do not contain our name?
This is the question that matters and the one most reports hide. If someone types your business name, they already know you. Google will show you first whatever the state of your site. The growth is in the other searches: the service, the place, the question.
Look for two figures. Impressions, which is how many times a page of yours appeared in results. And the number of distinct searches that triggered it. The second is the one to watch. More distinct searches means Google trusts more of your pages to answer more questions.
On the clinic site, impressions per day went from about 300 the week before launch to 556 in the third month, while the number of distinct searches went from 157 to 682. Four times as many different questions, most of them without the clinic's name. Those are the future patients. The report says so plainly instead of just drawing the line.
Question 2: where do we stand on the searches that bring money?
Not all searches are equal. A dive shop cares about the Open Water course plus the island, a villa about its neighborhood plus the word villa, a clinic about its specialty plus the town. A good report lists these searches by name, with the average position and the clicks for each. It says what moved.
Position matters more than people think. Top three on a phone is the screen. Position seven is a scroll most people never make. So the report should count how many of your money searches sit in the top three and track that count month after month.
For the clinic, 29 local searches ranked in the top three after three months. In its main town it sat first on every variant of the search, with an average position between 1.0 and 1.5. In its second, larger location it ranked between third and fourth. The report said exactly that. It said that the next months of work go there. A report that only celebrates is not telling you where the work is.
Question 3: what did visitors do once they arrived?
Traffic is not the goal. A visit that ends on the booking button, the phone number or the contact form is. The report should count those actions, because they are the closest thing to a sale that a website can measure.
Three figures tell the story: clicks on the booking tool or the main call to action, clicks on the phone number from a phone and forms sent. Divide the first by the number of visits and you have the share of visits that showed an intention to buy. Watch that share more than the raw visits, because it tells you whether the pages convince.
On the clinic site, 6,989 visits produced 2,735 clicks to online booking, 375 clicks on the phone number and 15 contact forms. Thirty-nine percent of visits reached the booking button. Seventy-two percent of visitors were on a phone, which is why the booking button sits on every screen.
Question 4: what are you going to do about it next month?
The last section is the one that proves someone read the numbers. It names the searches that are close to the top three and could be pushed over, the page that gets traffic but no clicks, the question people type that no page answers yet. Then it says what will be done: a new page, a rewritten one, a change on the Google Business Profile.
If the report has no such section, nobody is steering. The numbers are being collected, not used. On our monthly plan this section is the deliverable. The hour of changes included each month is often spent exactly there.
What a report should also admit
The honest reports include their limits. Here are the ones we write down every month.
A click to a booking tool is an intention, not an appointment. The appointments live in your booking system, so the report should invite you to compare. Branded searches inflate the clicks: on the clinic site about two thirds of Google clicks came from searches containing the clinic's name. The gains were in the other third. Three months is short. Island business is seasonal, so a month should be compared with the same month a year earlier once that history exists.
Finally, the report should say where every number comes from and let you open the tool yourself. Search Console and analytics are set up in your accounts, not ours. If a provider refuses that, ask why.
A five-minute read, not a dozen charts
Put together, a good report fits on two pages. Four questions, a dozen numbers that matter, a few words on what changed and a short list of what happens next. You read it with your coffee, you know where you stand and you know what you are paying for.
That is the report included in our monthly plan, built the same way for a restaurant, a dive center or a clinic. If your current one does not answer the four questions, send it to us with a free site review and we will tell you what it is missing.
Common questions
Which tools do these numbers come from?
Two free ones. Google Search Console shows what Google did with your site: impressions, clicks, searches and positions. A privacy-friendly analytics tool shows what visitors did on the site: pages read, clicks on the booking button or the phone number, forms sent. Both belong to you and both stay with you.
How soon after launch does a report mean anything?
The first month tells you whether Google found the pages. Positions and clicks need three months to settle. A fair comparison needs the same month a year earlier because island business is seasonal. We say so in the report rather than dress up an early month.
Can I check the numbers myself?
Yes. You should. Both tools are set up in your own accounts, with us added as a user. Every figure in the report can be opened in the tool it came from. A report you cannot verify is an opinion.
Related articles
Why an Instagram page is not a website
What the account cannot do and what a site adds.
Read the articleGoogle Business Profile for an island business: the fields that matter
The free listing most businesses leave half empty.
Read the articleOne language or four? Choosing languages for a Caribbean website
When English is enough and when it costs you customers.
Read the article